When selecting flooring for residential or light commercial builds, contractors often face the same question:
“Should I go with hardwood or LVP?”
Luxury vinyl plank (LVP) has exploded in popularity, but does it really outperform engineered hardwood where it counts?
Let’s break it down—with real-world contractor priorities in mind: cost, installation speed, client satisfaction, and long-term ROI.
1. Visual Impact & Client Perception
Engineered Hardwood (Oak):
- Real wood = authentic grain, depth, and warmth
- Every plank is unique
- High-end clients expect real materials in premium homes
LVP:
- Printed layer simulates wood look
- Repeats patterns every few planks
- Feels less substantial underfoot
“We win more upscale clients when we show real oak samples. The difference is obvious.” — Contractor, Austin TX
2. Durability & Performance
| Feature | Engineered Hardwood | LVP |
|---|---|---|
| Surface Wear | Durable UV-cured coating | High scratch resistance |
| Moisture Resistance | Moderate (with underlayment) | Excellent (100% waterproof) |
| Denting / Compression | Resists everyday wear | Can dent under heavy loads |
| Lifespan | 20–25+ years | 8–15 years |
Key takeaway:
LVP is great for basements, mudrooms, or rentals, but engineered hardwood is better for living areas, resale homes, and value-driven spaces.
3. Installation Speed & Flexibility
Both materials can be installed quickly, but engineered wood offers more visual payoff.
- Engineered hardwood supports floating, glue-down, or nail-down methods
- LVP usually clicks into place—but subfloor prep is still crucial
- Both can go over concrete or plywood with proper underlayment
Pro Tip: Pre-finished engineered oak planks from Finefloor can be installed just as quickly as LVP, with longer-lasting results.
4. Resale Value & Client Satisfaction
- Buyers value real materials. Hardwood floors consistently increase home resale value
- LVP is often viewed as budget-friendly or temporary
- Designers prefer wood in key areas like kitchens, dining rooms, and living spaces
“I’ve had clients rip out LVP and replace it with wood—even after a few years.” — Renovation Contractor, NJ
5. Environmental Considerations
- Finefloor’s engineered oak is available with FSC® and FloorScore® certification
- LVP is made from PVC (plastic), raising sustainability and indoor air quality concerns
- Hardwood is renewable and recyclable when responsibly sourced
Final Verdict: Choose Based on the Project
| Choose Engineered Hardwood If… |
|---|
| You’re building a higher-end home or condo unit |
| You need to impress buyers or tenants |
| The client wants long-term value + real wood feel |
| You want faster installation than solid hardwood |
| Choose LVP If… |
|---|
| You’re working on wet-prone areas (e.g., basement) |
| Budget is very tight |
| The property is a short-term rental or commercial unit |
Why Contractors Trust Finefloor Engineered Oak
- Precision-milled planks for fast, clean installs
- Stable multilayer core for wide climates
- Durable pre-finished surfaces
- Consistent stock in U.S. warehouses
- Backed by real service and technical support